I haven’t really thought about this yet, but LargeHearted Boy has an amazingly comprehensive set of links to various lists if you feel like perusing.
I can tell you one album I see on a lot of lists that will not be on mine: TV on the Radio “Return to Cookie Mountain”. It was darkroom-tested and rejected. Not a cohesive album. No songs that jumped out and said “PLAY ME AGAIN!” which is really the ultimate test.